TL;DR
Get furniture and decor delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
A House Beautiful report featuring professional organizers challenges two familiar decluttering rules: removing one item for every purchase and discarding clothes not worn in a year. The organizers say regular home reviews, available storage and an item’s fit with a person’s life are more useful guides than automatic cutoffs.
A House Beautiful report says professional organizers are questioning two common decluttering rules: “one in, one out” and the advice to discard clothes that have not been worn in a year. Organizers quoted in the report say these rules can be too rigid, and suggest instead using regular reviews, practical storage limits and an item’s relevance to the owner’s life.
Under the “one in, one out” rule, a person removes an existing possession whenever they bring a new one home. Kenika Williams, founder of Tidied by K., told House Beautiful that the idea may work for some people, but she does not think every purchase should trigger a purge. Jayna Lattimore, founder of Ordered Professional Organizing, similarly describes decluttering as an ongoing household routine rather than a reaction to each purchase.
Lattimore says periodic sweeps can help people remove things they no longer use or need, without requiring a matching item to be discarded whenever something new arrives. Williams says the more practical test is whether a purchase has a functional place in the home. Lattimore adds that an organizing system should leave some room for growth; when drawers, shelves and closets are already full, even a small addition can make the system harder to maintain.
The second rule sets a one-year deadline for clothing that has not been worn. Millie Naor, founder of Bella Organizers, says some infrequently worn items may still be meaningful enough to keep, while advising people to limit how many such pieces take up space. Beth Ruck, founder of Conquering Clutter, says elapsed time alone is not the best way to decide. She suggests considering whether a garment works with other clothes and whether it suits the owner’s current lifestyle.
A More Flexible Approach to Clutter
The advice matters because both rules turn a personal household decision into a fixed test: buy something and discard something, or pass a date and donate a garment. The organizers quoted in the report argue that these shortcuts can lead to unnecessary purging or make organizing feel like a constant accounting exercise.
Their alternative is not to ignore accumulation. It is to judge new purchases by whether they have a place and review belongings routinely, while making clothing decisions based on use, fit and personal value. For readers, that means the rules can be treated as optional tools rather than universal requirements. The report does not establish that one approach works for everyone; the recommendations are organizers’ professional opinions.
modular storage bins for closet organization
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Rules Under Review
Both guidelines are widely recognizable pieces of organizing advice: one links each incoming item to an outgoing one, while the other uses a year without wear as a signal to let clothing go. House Beautiful’s report spoke with professional organizers about whether those rules remain practical for everyday households.
The organizers do not reject decluttering or regular editing. Their concern is with applying a strict trigger regardless of circumstances. A rarely worn item may still be special, and a new purchase may fit a home that has planned capacity. Conversely, a purchase without a designated place or a garment that no longer suits its owner may prompt a useful review.
““I don’t think every purchase needs to trigger a purge.””
— Kenika Williams, founder of Tidied by K., as quoted by House Beautiful
No One-Size-Fits-All Test
The report presents organizers’ recommendations, not findings from a comparative study, and it does not establish that these approaches produce better outcomes for every household. It also does not quantify how common either rule is or how many people find them difficult to follow.
Individual circumstances remain relevant. The report does not set a universal amount of spare storage to keep or specify how many rarely worn garments are reasonable. It leaves those decisions to each person’s space, routines, wardrobe needs and priorities.
Review Items on Your Schedule
The practical next step suggested by the organizers is to schedule periodic household reviews rather than wait for a purchase or an anniversary to prompt action. During a review, people can identify belongings they no longer use, check whether new items have a functional home and leave some capacity in storage systems where possible.
For clothes, the cited advice is to ask whether an item works with the rest of the wardrobe, fits the owner’s current lifestyle and is worth the space it occupies. The report offers no formal timetable or follow-up study; these are individual organizing suggestions, not a new standard that households are required to adopt.
Key Questions
Which two decluttering rules does the report challenge?
It questions “one in, one out”—removing one possession for each new purchase—and the advice to discard clothes that have not been worn in a year.
Does one in, one out still work for some people?
Yes. Williams says people can keep using the rule if it works for them. Her objection is to making every purchase automatically trigger a purge.
How should I decide whether to keep clothes I rarely wear?
The organizers quoted suggest considering whether the garment suits your current lifestyle, goes with other clothes and is special enough to justify the space it takes. Naor also recommends limiting the number of such items.
What does the report suggest instead of strict rules?
It points to regular reviews, giving belongings functional storage and keeping some room in organizing systems. These are recommendations from organizers, not a universal formula.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
